Page 5 - i1052-5173-32-8
P. 5

The United States currently has ~1400
                                       Housatonic (10 Mt)
                                       Housatonic (10 Mt)   A                   thermonuclear warheads deployed on land-
                                       Housatonic (10 Mt)
                       150
                    atmospheric bomb-test  yield (Mt/y)  100  Mike (10.4 Mt) Mike (10.4 Mt) Mike (10.4 Mt)  Yankee (13.5 Mt) Yankee (13.5 Mt) Yankee (13.5 Mt)  (~50 Mt  USA (>8Mt)  another  ~400  at  U.S.  Air Force  bases
                                 T Ts
                                 Tsarsarar
                                                                                and submarine-based ballistic missiles and
                                bomba
                                bomba
                                bomba
                                (~50 Mt))
                                (~50 Mt)
                                                                                (Kristensen and Korda, 2021). A recent
                                                USSR (>8Mt)
                                                                                estimate of Russian nuclear-weapon deploy-
                                                                                ment is similar (Kristensen and Korda,
                        50
                                                                                2022). Both nations have several thousand
                         0
                                                                                available for deployment, with a total of
                        1950     1960      1970     1980     1990               additional nuclear warheads in storage and
                                                                                ~8300 warheads and bombs available for
                        2.0                 23  Pu +  240       200             use in a major nuclear war. NATO members
                                                Pu falloutalloutPu fallout B
                      239 Pu +  240 Pu (PBq)  1.5  1377 Cs f    150  137 Cs (PBq)  weapons. The nuclear-weapon arsenal of
                                                Pu f
                                            239+240
                                            239+2409
                                                                                France and UK have another ~500 nuclear
                                             Cs f
                                             Cs falloutalloutallout
                                            137
                                            13
                                                                                the United States is intended to defend the
                                                                                30 member nations of NATO, with a popu-
                        1.0
                                                                100
                                             Cs f
                                             Cs fallout remainingallout remainingallout remaining
                                             Cs f
                                            1377
                                                                                lation of ~950 million, plus an additional
                                            13
                                            137
                                            in 2012
                                            in 2012
                                            in 2012
                                                                                200 million people in Japan, South Korea,
                                                                50
                        0.5
                                                                                and Australia. The Russian arsenal is
                                                                                intended to defend the ~146 million people
                        0.0                                     0
                         1950     1960     1970      1980     1990              in Russia plus the additional 47 million
                                                                                people in allied countries of the Collective
                       1000                                                     Security Treaty Organization.
                                              >45°
                                              >45°
                           Jan. 1, 196
                           Jan. 1, 1963       >45° NNN      C
                           Jan. 1, 19633
                       800                                                        The primary targets of Russian and
                                              >10° S
                                              >10° SS
                                              >10°                              American nuclear weapons are the nuclear
                      ∆ 14  C (‰)  400                                          1987). Stationary land-based missile sites
                                                                                weapons of the opposing countries (Hafner,
                       600
                                                                                would be targeted with the intent of destroy-
                       200                                                      ing the missiles before launch. Other mili-
                                                                                tary facilities, including those in and near
                         0                                                      cities, would be targeted, with higher-eleva-
                         1950     1960     1970     1980      1990              tion detonation for more dispersed targets.
                                           year                                 The number and types of non-military tar-
                                                                                gets, including infrastructure, industry, and
                  Figure 1. (A) Histogram of annual yield, in megatons of TNT equivalent, for
                  atmospheric nuclear-bomb tests (UNSCEAR, 2000; USDOE, 2015). Atomic   cities, is not public knowledge, but enor-
                  bomb-test yields before the first thermonuclear bomb test in 1952 are too   mous destruction and loss of life could
                  small to plot at the scale shown. Names of some major tests are also   result from attack on these targets with a
                  shown. Atmospheric testing by the United States (USA) and Union of
                  Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) ended with the 1963 Partial Test Ban   small fraction of either nation’s nuclear
                  Treaty. Later atmospheric tests were conducted by China and France.    forces (Glasstone, 2020).
                  (B) Combined  239 Pu and  240 Pu fallout as calculated from more readily mea-
                  sured  137 Cs and  Sr fallout, with higher (  239 Pu+ 240 Pu)/ 137 Cs in earlier U.S.
                              90
                  (neutron-rich) tests versus later Soviet tests (Koide et al., 1985; UNSCEAR,   NUCLEAR WINTER
                  2000; Hancock et al., 2014). (C) Graph of C as measured in tree rings and
                                              14
                  in the atmosphere showing the high values measured at sites >45° N and   Nuclear winter is the concept that, during
                  low values measured at sites >10° S before global atmospheric mixing   a major nuclear war, firestorms caused by
                  (modified from fig. 4 of Hua et al., 2021).
                                                                                nuclear explosions will engulf cities and
                                                                                inject smoke into the stratosphere where it
                                                                                will spread around the globe and reduce
         atmosphere contain  C rather than stable   NUCLEAR WAR                 sunlight at ground level to the point where
                         14
         12 C or  C (e.g., Dutta, 2016). Neutrons pro-  Radioisotope fallout in the mid-twentieth   winter-like conditions persist for months or
              13
         duced by  nuclear  explosions  also cause   century occurred during  the  development   years (e.g., Crutzen and Birks, 1982; Turco
         transformation of  N to  C. Thermonuclear-  and  deployment  of  thousands  of  nuclear   et al., 1983, 1990). The severity of a nuclear
                           14
                      14
         bomb tests during 1952–1962 produced so   weapons by North Atlantic Treaty Org-  winter would depend on the fuel load and
         much  C that concentrations of  C in atmo-  anization (NATO) nations and the USSR.   flammability of targeted areas as well as
                                 14
             14
         spheric CO  almost doubled (Fig. 1C; Hua et   The military posture represented by these   atmospheric conditions and other environ-
                 2
         al., 2021). Elevated  C concentrations are   nuclear weapons, known as “mutual assured   mental factors. While the primary targets of
                         14
         measurable in tree rings and ice cores (e.g.,   destruction,” ensures a catastrophic nuclear   U.S. and Russian nuclear weapons are the
         Levchenko et al., 1996) and have been pro-  response to a major nuclear attack, thus   opposing nation’s nuclear weapons and
         posed as the most precise geologic marker   restraining adversaries as long as those in   command and control infrastructure, most
         for the beginning of the Anthropocene   charge behave rationally and command and   of which are not particularly large or flam-
         (Turney et al., 2018).              control infrastructure performs as intended.  mable, potential secondary targets include
                                                                                          www.geosociety.org/gsatoday  5
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10